August 19, 2016
UnitedHealth expects to lose $850 million on Obamacare in 2016, while Aetna, Anthem, and Humana are all on track to lose at least $300 million each on their ACA plans this year, according to company reports and estimates from Bloomberg Intelligence. UnitedHealth says it’s quitting 31 of the 34 states where it sells ACA policies. Humana is exiting 8 of 19 states and reducing its presence to just 156 counties, from 1,351 a year ago. Anthem hasn’t announced plans to change its participation in the program.
On Aug. 15, Aetna said it will stop selling Obamacare plans in 11 of the 15 states where it had participated in the program, reversing its plan to expand into five new state exchanges in 2017. “The exchanges are a mess as they exist today,” says Aetna Chief Executive Officer Mark Bertolini. “They’re losing a lot of money for a lot of people.”
Source: Obamacare’s in Trouble as Insurers Tire of Losing Money – Bloomberg
August 18, 2016
And it is because of those losses that we are seeing what looks more than a little like the start of a health insurance death spiral in the exchanges. This is far from certain, and will depend in significant part on the results of the next open enrollment period, which starts later this year, as well as the decisions made by other health insurers under the law. But there are a number of warning signals to be watching.
We know what a health insurance death spiral looks like because we’ve seen them before, in states such as New York, New Jersey, and Washington. The experience in those states varied somewhat, but they all shared several essential qualities: The states put in place regulations requiring health insurers to sell to all comers (guaranteed issue), and strictly limiting the ways that insurance could be priced based on individual health history such as preexisting conditions (community rating). As a result, insurers ended up with large numbers of very sick customers who were very expensive to cover. Because they were subject to limits on how they could price health history, they responded by signficantly raising premiums for everyone. The new, higher premiums caused the healthiest, most price sensitive people to drop coverage entirely, which caused insurers to raise premiums further, resulting in yet more individuals dropping coverage, and so on and so forth, until all that remained was very small group of very sick, very expensive individuals.
Source: The Return of the Obamacare Death Spiral – Hit & Run : Reason.com
August 17, 2016
Exhibit 1 compares insurers’ projected per-member-per-month (pmpm) medical expenses with actual medical claims for ACA-compliant individual coverage in 2014.10 Across the market, medical claims were 5.7 percent higher than projected ($429 vs. $406 pmpm). Some insurers did considerably worse than others. The quartile of insurers with the highest claims (75th percentile) underestimated their claims by an average of 35 percent, whereas the lowest-claim quartile projected their claims much more accurately, within 4 percent, on average, similar to the average claims underestimate of 6 percent marketwide.
Source: How Has the Affordable Care Act Affected Health Insurers’ Financial Performance? – The Commonwealth Fund
August 17, 2016
HuffPo reporters write of Aetna’s CEO Mark Bertolini: “he made a clear threat: If President Barack Obama‘s administration refused to allow the merger to proceed, he wrote, Aetna would be in worse financial position and would have to withdraw from most of its Obamacare markets, and quite likely all of them.”
It turns out this “threat” was a direct answer to a question the DOJ ordered Aetna to answer.
“Explain how [the transaction being blocked] affect Aetna’s business strategy and operations, including Aetna’s participation on the public exchanges related to the Affordable Care Act and any products or geographic areas in which Aetna may withdraw or reduce operations,” the DOJ demanded.
Source: DOJ demanded Aetna explain how merger-block would affect the insurer’s exchange participation | Washington Examiner
August 17, 2016
Some Obamacare backers had argued the nation’s third-largest carrier is trying to strong-arm the Obama administration into approving its controversial merger with Humana, and new evidence suggests they might be right.
Aetna has loudly denied that it’s exiting Obamacare exchanges because of a Justice Department lawsuit, but last month CEO Mark Bertolini expressly warned the Obama administration that the company would do exactly that.
Source: Aetna warned DOJ: Sue us, and we scale back on Obamacare – POLITICO
July 13, 2016
What’s happening in North Carolina is repeating itself in state after state across the country and represents the most acute structural threat to the marquee achievement of President Barack Obama’s presidency. A POLITICO review of 2015 financial filings from nearly 100 health plans across a dozen geographically and politically diverse states found that less than a quarter of them hit the standard break-even point for insurers, at which payouts are kept to about 85 percent of premiums taken in. And 40 percent of them had medical costs that outright exceeded the premiums they brought in. The bottom line: many of those insurers lost tens of millions of dollars on their Obamacare policies last year.
Source: Obamacare’s sinking safety net
July 12, 2016
Haislmaier said that in the individual health insurance market, 15 companies had to pay penalties despite having a loss ratio of greater 116 percent, meaning that for every $1 they collected in premiums, they paid out $1.16 in claims. Yet those companies had to pay an average risk adjustment penalty of 7.7 percent of their premiums.
Source: Obamacare Going Bust | LifeZette